translation missing: en.skip_to_nav translation missing: en.skip_to_content

Free shipping on $125+ in the US ● Free 30 day returns

  • Imperfect Paola Sand
  • Imperfect Paola Sand
  • Imperfect Paola Sand
  • Imperfect Paola Sand
  • Imperfect Paola Sand

Imperfect Paola Sand

Last Units



Final sale

7 reviews

Handmade in Florence, Italy. An ultra light and versatile penny loafer with a square toe and a ‘90’s vibe.



This style runs large, we recommend sizing down a size.

Find your shoe size with our Shoe Sizer


Tag @maguireshoes on Instagram

Customer Reviews
3.7 Based on 7 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
Canada Canada
I recommend this product

Needs a Wide Foot Option

I feel like I have been breaking these in for a while (almost two months now). It's well made, but not comfortable. I figured a loafer would be good for my wide feet, but it really isnt. It would be great if this came in narrow and wide. I also think they are slightly overpriced.

  • Particularities Wide FeetFlat Feet
Canada Canada
I recommend this product

Look cute but Incredibly uncomfortable

These loafers look nice, but they are the least comfortable shoes I’ve ever had, which is unfortunate given their price. I’ve spent close to $30 on different inserts and padding to make them more comfortable but legitimately every time I wear them for more than 20 minutes my heels are bleeding from somewhere new. I’m a shoe lover, so I’m very well aware of a good break in, but I’ve tried wearing these on several different occasions and everytime I end up limping and bleeding. It also doesn’t seem to be a sizing issue as they fit me well - I wouldn’t go bigger or smaller. When I contacted the company about this, I simply asked them if they had any tips about how to make them more comfortable. I got a pretty dismissive response telling me to sell them if I wasn’t happy. I’m not going to sell someone a pair of shoes that are literally causing my feet harm. It’s too bad because I want to love this company, but I won’t be buying from here again!

  • Usual size 37
  • Purchased 37 EUR
Canada Canada
I recommend this product

Pas confortables du tout

C'est un beau modèle mais contrairement aux autres avis, elles ne sont pas du tout confortable pour moi. La semelle très épaisse ne rend pas les chaussures pliable pour la marche, ça me donne une marche de canard. Puis l'arrière me fait horriblement mal. Je dois les revendre...

  • Usual size 35
  • Fit Fits smallTrue to sizeFits large
  • Purchased 35 EUR
  • Particularities Pieds larges

You may also like